question...

[isonuZ]

i heard that singing may help...
my question is, is it bad to sing hight tempo songs or it will help?
some pple say it's good, cz it makes you a little fluent...
other say bad, cz it makes you talk faster ==> making you stutter more
which is the correct answer?

[Lenny]

what ever works for YOU is what counts.

of course it depends on what key the rest of the people are in.

[isonuZ]

of course it depends on what key the rest of the people are in.
what do u mean?

[Bruce]

i think he was being sarcastic, certainly if you could sing all the time instead of talking you probably would not stutter but how could you walk around and do that????

[Fredrick]

if a person couid find a way to do talking in a very slight sing-song way then they would be approximating most of the fluency shaping programs including Hollins....

[ahhyes]

Hey isonuZ. Singing really does not make you more fluent.
There's a professional singer out there. Forgot the name but he is a stutter but does NOT stutter when he sings. When he stops sing that's when he goes back to his normal voice and situation.

What singing does in my opinion is that it helps you feel better. Cuz that's when you are probably must fluent.

Brandon

[vwagner]

Singing uses a different part of the brain than speech. That is why you can sing fluently.

[isonuZ]

oh well...
thx

[Bruce]

Singing uses a different part of the brain than speech. That is why you can sing fluently.

uh, when you sing you are using both parts of the brain not only one DR.

look if this guy sings and does not stutter that is fine but the question is:

HOW GOOD IS HIS SINGING??????